
How the Sill and Frame Pick Insert or Full-Frame
An insert, or pocket window, is a complete unit that slides into the existing frame once the old sash and balances are pulled, leaving the outside trim and inside casing in place. A full-frame unit removes the whole old window back to the rough opening, the hole the framing leaves for a window, which lets us see that framing, repair it and flash it.
Fine Homebuilding and This Old House draw the same line we do: an insert suits a frame that is square, level and sound, while a rotted or out-of-square frame needs full-frame. The Department of Energy's Building America checklist labels full-frame the recommended option and says the space behind an old window's trim was often never sealed against air.
On older capital-area houses, ice dams often leave a sill (the frame's lowest board, which takes runoff from the glass) soft under good paint, and an insert set on it only covers the rot. Where we go full-frame, a sill pan (a shaped tray under the window that drains any leak to the outside) goes in first, then flashing tape lapped into the house wrap so water on the tape always lands outside the layer beneath.











